My blogging nightmare – What I hope this blog does not become

My blogging nightmare – What I hope this blog does not become

Every now and then an idea for a post comes to me, and I can write an outline that’s 90% complete in a matter of minutes. The last one is here – Without the Lord the work is in vain.

With that said, apologies if this comes across too strong, anyway, here we go…

With the ChurchTrain blog, I want to stay focused: I want to help people, realising my passion to see churches succeed (rather than suck) at websites, social media, design and other forms of communication.

If this leads to you wanting to hire my services, be that for design, training, or video production – awesome, I’d love to work with you if we’re a good fit!

However…

Little disclaimer first. I work really hard to keep things positive here. As I’ve said before, my intention is never to ‘name and shame’, even when I see churches failing to communicate; even when I see failed attempts that make me want to bang my head against a wall.

This pursuit of positivity over negativity isn’t entirely self-sacrificial (gosh that sounds overly dramatic). Quick tip – positive messages are much more likely to be enjoyed and shared online (Buffer). Also see the ‘Emotive Content Gets Shared’ section of this post from Hootsuite.

But anyway, whatever the reasons, I try to prefer ‘thumbs up’ over ‘thumbs down’.

Right, disclaimer over.

There are blogs out there that are launched with best intentions, starting out with a passion to make a difference. Great! This is what we want to see – quality content, focused on an area of interest.

However, over time, the blog meanders, as these things do. Sometimes there’s a lack of attention, shown by a low frequency of posts. Sometimes the posts are as frequent as ever, but it’s easy to see the passion has gone, and the writers are just phoning it in. It happens, which is why I wrote my recent post about how to keep blogging.

On the other hand, some blogs do the opposite – they thrive. Good, frequent content leads to success in many forms, with comments galore, backlinks from all directions and growing social media followings.

It’s at this point that there is a stumbling block to avoid, and here is where I throw caution to the wind, and briefly embrace negativity. I find it really hard to see bloggers who have sites that are thriving who seem to get a bit wrapped up in their own success, however subtly.

The result, the blog gets too inward focused.

Perhaps the blog, as an out working of the blogger’s genuine passion, gains enough traction to make money. This is something that many, if not all bloggers would welcome with open arms – the ability to post blog content whilst being paid to do so.

Please don’t think I’m against this idea – but making money from blogging doesn’t come without it’s pitfalls.

The problem is, the site can – almost has to – become obsessed with the types of growth I mentioned before. It becomes the writer’s own little empire of page views, online followers and social shares. Why? Because if the blog fails to keep up with these signs of growth, the advertisers’ money can stop flowing as quickly as it started.

Over time these metrics, and growing them, become the most important thing.

The first and most obvious symptom, as far as I see it, is that the content suffers. Sharing amazing, helpful content now has to take a backseat to sharing any content that gets eyes on the blog, fulfilling the promises you make to advertisers. It’s all too easy in this scenario to forget about the passion you had at the start, where it was important to you that people read your content, interacting and engaging with it. What’s essential now is that people click it, see it, and see the ads. Hopefully they’ll click them too, then everyone’s happy, right?

Time for another disclaimer – not every person that successfully monetises their blog will be guilty of ‘selling out’. Many will handle the balance well.

For those that don’t, though, it seems to me that sharing ‘cheap’ content, is not only an abuse of the privilege – that is, the privilege of people coming and spending even a little of their time visiting your site. More than this, it’s unsustainable; far from everybody being happy, users will stop trusting you as a provider of quality blog posts, and will go elsewhere. Thus, the cycle continues as the blogger has to create content appealing to wider and wider audiences, travelling further from the blog’s niche – the original source of the passion.

Inevitably, the pageviews eventually fall away, and your blog is no longer worth advertisers’ cash. Only now, it’s not worth your readers’ time either.

So in the end, nobody’s happy.

As I was thinking about this, it struck me. This goes wider than blogs. there are charities, organisations – even churches out there who do exactly the same thing.

Churches are planted, businesses are launched with much excitement and zeal. This passion leads to exponential growth, and change and it’s all smiles until, over time, we realise we’ve reduced ourselves to getting bums on seats, at any cost.

The reason we started has been lost – for churches, this is all too often the central truths of the gospel, that we choose not to proclaim, fearing that we may challenge people, and they’d rather go elsewhere.

I’m reminded of the story behind the song ‘When the music fades’, where a church found that the music was becoming too much of a focus, and that they were needing to get back to basic gospel truth, without distractions – the passion that made them begin.

“There was a dynamic missing, so the pastor did a pretty brave thing,” he recalls. “He decided to get rid of the sound system and band for a season, and we gathered together with just our voices. His point was that we’d lost our way in worship, and the way to get back to the heart would be to strip everything away.”

crosswalk.com

The church went a while without using instruments in their worship, stripping it back to the basic reason of why they were doing any of it in the first place. Out of this came not only the song, but a renewed vision for the church’s worship.

As Peter Baker says, whose post helped to launch this very blog, ‘The main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing.’

If nothing else, hopefully this blog post will serve as a reminder to myself to stay true to the reasons I started this blog, and a challenge to myself if I don’t! I hope it does the same for you!

Was I too harsh? Share your views in the comments.

3 Responses

  1. Yes, you’re right! I’d love to make lots of money from my blog, and hope to, but I do have to keep checking my heart, and keep coming to God to find his purpose for my blog. And personally, I don’t like advertising (in general…I do share some affiliate links) as a way to make money. There are lots of other ways…I’m heading towards writing my own eBooks and eCourses which I pray will be a blessing to many, as well as bring in some money.

    • Joe

      Absolutely – it’s not wrong to want an income, or to aspire to it, but there are many ways to go about it. I’m leaning towards the same sort of thing you suggest, my only concern is the amount of eBooks that are out there these days. With that said, your content doesn’t have to compete with everything else that’s out there, it just has to be better than others in your niche!

  2. Interesting – lost of thoughts here. There are obviously different blogging cultures out there. 2 examples for me personally: I recently almost became a patheos.com listed blogger. In the end I didn’t because (as well as my blog losing some of its identity) you have to take on ads since Patheos is there to make revenue. On the other hand I am “kind of paid” to operator my company’s blog. Not paid per blog but one of my performance targets is 2 blogs per month.
    In the end of we are not blogging about topics we are passionate about it’aint worth reading. And …. there’s no such thing as a great blog any more, only a great post – you’re only as good as your last post 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *